Island Pizza Sanibel

Looking for the best pizza in Sanibel, Florida? The Island Pizza Company is the #1 pizza joint in the Sanibel Island area, so you don’t have to look very far to get a mouthwatering slice. The Island Pizza Company is a quaint and colorful family-run restaurant located on the island with over 30 years of experience. Not only can you find the classics, but they also have a wide variety of unique and innovative creations that combine flavors that no one else can match. With everything from chicken and pasta to all sorts of pizza, the Island Pizza Company only uses the freshest of ingredients to make their unique offerings. Best of all? It’s just minutes away from our vacation condos in Sanibel.

cheese pizza

What Can I Get?

You might be asking yourself, “I know they’ve got pizza, but what else is on the menu?” To start, they have plenty of crowd-favorite appetizers including calamari, mozzarella sticks, bruschetta, buffalo shrimp, and many other options. The local favorite, however, is the coconut shrimp. Served crispy and crunchy, the shrimp are rolled into coconut shreds and served with a teriyaki pineapple sauce. Looking for something more Italian? Their classic toasted ravioli is a deep-fried breaded ravioli is stuffed with ricotta and served with their signature marinara sauce. 

For the main course, there are their signature pizzas. You can find all your classic favorites in the Margherita, Hawaiian, and Mediterranean pizzas.

What people really come for, however, are their signature pizzas that you cannot find anywhere else. The “South of the Border” pizza is made with olive oil, Alfredo sauce, garlic, chicken, parmesan, mozzarella, pepper jack, feta, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, and chili powder. There is also the “Islander,” which is made with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ham, mushrooms, tomatoes, black olives, green peppers, and onions. For a truly unique pizza dining experience, the Island Pizza Company’s signature pizzas are the way to go. 

Looking for entrees that are not pizza? Fear not! There is plenty of classic Italian fare including lasagna, spaghetti with meatballs, Caprese salad, and Rigatoni with sausage pasta. The Island Pizza Company also has a plethora of signature sandwiches for you to choose from. They have their classic chicken and meatball parmesan sandwiches, but everyone comes for their buffalo chicken sandwich. Breaded and fried, the buffalo chicken sandwich is then tossed in buffalo sauce with a blue cheese dressing. It is a favorite amongst locals and will for sure please anyone in your family. 

pizza and chicken wings

The Island Pizza Company also serves a wide variety of chicken wings. Each order comes with twelve chicken wings, and you can choose from barbecue, honey garlic, sweet and sour, honey hot, teriyaki, and their signature Sanibel island sauce. Looking for a dessert? Ask about their house-made desserts that are made fresh every day! The Island Pizza Company rotates its dessert offerings daily, so you can be sure to have a new experience and surprise every time you come in to dine. 

How to Order

With a large menu and a welcoming atmosphere, the Island Pizza Company is a great option for all those searching for the best Sanibel Island restaurants. You will not be disappointed with your choice, and their family-run staff will make sure that your experience is the way you want it. With COVID-19 measures, the Island Pizza Company has made sure their full menu and wine list are available for delivery during their regular operating hours. To browse the full menu, feel free to check out their website for full details. Their restaurant is also doing dine-in but with a limited capacity of ten people at a time. 

On your next visit to Sanibel Island, make sure to stop by Island Pizza Company. You’ll be welcomed with a great meal and a comfortable atmosphere to enjoy with the ones you love. Contact us today to start booking your getaway in one of our Sanibel condo rentals!